EU low-cal diet industry "could fold" if rules rubber stamped, warns trade body

The European Commission has asked EFSA for help on how best to regulate such low-calorie diets across the EU. ©iStock/hannahgleg

New rules on low calorie diets could wipe out manufacturers and distributors of weight loss programmes in Europe, according to an industry trade body which is urging regulators to seek a compromise agreement.

Low calorie diets (LCD:800-1200 calories a day) and very low calorie diets (VLCD:400-800 calories a day) are niche and are often prescribed by healthcare professionals to patients suffering from clinical obesity.

They contain regular food ingredients, such as vegetables, soya, milk, fat and pasta in dried form.

Amid growing levels of obesity, and the financial strain on healthcare providers of meeting this challenge, the European Commission called on the European Foods Standards Agency (EFSA) to produce a report to help it decide on how best to regulate such low-calorie diets across the EU. Regulators thought the previous guidance had become outdated.

While the EFSA report was welcomed by the pan European group, Specialised Nutrition European (SNE), saying it could help "tackle the societal challenges of obesity," the VLCD industry group- whose LCD and VLCD members operate across Europe-has warned the new legislation could prove disastrous for its members and consumers.

Essential that rules are looked at again

Speaking to NuraIngredients, professor Anthony Leeds, medical director of the VLCD Industry Group, said the VLCD industry "could fold" and it was "essential that these rules are looked at again and that a compromise is reached in order to ensure the continued existence of these vital products."

“This proposed new legislation is going to have catastrophic effects on ordinary consumers simply wanting to manage their weight loss,” Dr Leeds told us.

Despite the plea, time is running out, as the proposals are set to be rubber stamped by the European parliament in the coming months, thus becoming law.

Should the VLCD Industry Group’s dire prediction come true then the fortunes of leading companies in this field such as Nestlé, Cambridge Weight Plan and Lightlife, could take a tumble.

The VLCD Industry Group’s argument is centred on new rules on composition which it argues would make diets "very difficult to manufacture" and would "taste unpleasant, have an unappealing texture, go off quite quickly and be much more expensive for consumers."

Protein levels too high

For example, Dr Leeds points to new rules demanding that diet replacement regimes should contain a minimum of 75 grams (g) of protein, compared to previous demands of 50g.

“The evidence that you need these higher amounts of protein is not that strong,” he told us.

The trade body is also unhappy about new demands on levels of essential fatty acids (11g for linoleic acids and 1.4g for alpha linoleic) and says overall the new demands will lead to "a sharp increase in production costs."

A further point of contention, according to Dr Leeds, is that the original EFSA document was not put out for consultation before being submitted to the European Commission.

The VLCD Industry Group is now calling on MEPs to reject the proposals and has put forward a compromise agreement, which would include a 60g minimum level of protein and a 6g minimum level of linoleic acids and 0.7g minimum level of alpha linoleic.

It argues the compromise agreement would provide "high consumer protection" whilst "addressing manufacturers’ food technological problems."

Related News

UPDATE: EFSA maintains guidance on vitamin K

UPDATE: EFSA maintains guidance on vitamin K

© iStock

FoodDrinkEurope calls for industry action on better nutrition


The death of diet foods? EU Parliament approve laws that could 'wipe out' very low calorie diet products

Low-calorie cranberry juice may aid blood pressure lowering efforts

EFSA: Products should be "safe and suitable when consumed as a sole source of nutrition for several weeks to months by overweight or obese adults"

600 calories, 75 g protein, 30 g carbs: EFSA issues ‘milestone’ diet replacement opinion

SNE: “We urge European decision makers to now translate this updated scientific evidence into legislation..."

Industry backs EFSA report on low-calorie diet regimes

A low calorie whey protein and fibre drink before breakfast reduced peak glucose levels in finger-prick blood tests by 2.1 mmol/L at 45 minutes

Low calorie whey-guar mix may help reduce blood sugar: Study

Oatmeal for breakfast may increase satiety and mean a lower calorie lunch

Oatmeal for breakfast may increase satiety and mean a lower calorie lunch

Nutrient levels are considered a key regulator of fat browning and a treatment that can increase the number of brown fat-like cells to burn more calories may be possible. (©

Protein-based nutrient sensor could provoke calorie burning in obesity battle: Study

Related Products

See more related products

Submit a comment

Your comment has been saved

Post a comment

Please note that any information that you supply is protected by our Privacy and Cookie Policy. Access to all documents and request for further information are available to all users at no costs, In order to provide you with this free service, William Reed Business Media SAS does share your information with companies that have content on this site. When you access a document or request further information from this site, your information maybe shared with the owners of that document or information.