Should caffeine be regulated? Expert suggests stimulant should carry warning labels due to potential dangers

Should caffeine be regulated? Expert suggests need for warning labels

As the use of caffeine in foods and drinks continues to grow, so do the risks. And calls for tighter regulations on the substance are becoming louder.

From functional foods to flavoured water, kids soft drinks and yoghurt, the use of caffeine in a wide range of food and drink products continues to grow at a rapid rate. And because of such rapid growth in use, caffeine is now being consumed in such high quantities that it should be considered for regulation,  according to one expert.

Professor Jack James from Reykjavik University, Iceland, suggested that the 'lethality' of caffeine is being underestimated because of widespread conceptions that it is harmless. However, with the stimulant now appearing in many everyday foods, drinks, medicines and toiletries, the expert warned that we are unwittingly consuming or exposed to more than we realise.

James - who is also editor-in-chief of the Journal of Caffeine Research, where the editorial appears - said caffeine has caused 'untimely deaths' and is a potentially lethal substance that should be regulated in similar ways to alcohol and cigarettes.

Caffeine dangers
James argued that caffeine-related toxicity, deaths, and near-deaths are an undeniable fact.

Indeed, he noted that a host of recent research has also suggested that that caffeine - often in the form of energy drinks - also counteracts the sedating effects of alcohol, and therefore encourages people to drink more.

Furthermore, he noted a 'growing body of evidence' to indicats that compared to alcohol alone, adding caffeine increases the risk having unprotected sex, experiencing or committing sexual assault, drink driving and violent assaults.

Regulatory vacuum

Among other things, the expert suggested new labelling requirements, restrictions on advertising, possible taxation, and age restrictions that would ban the sale of caffeinated products to young children.

Such new requirements could include labels on products that clearly display the level of caffeine that they contain, he said - arguing that the increasing trend for children to consume high levels of

drinks is exacerbating the problem.  

While some countries in Europe and Scandinavia have begun to take some regulatory action, including sales restrictions and product labelling, James warned that most countries including the UK and the U.S.A, have a ‘regulatory vacuum’ when it comes to caffeine.   

Such a lack of regulation "seems far from acceptable or prudent," said James.

Related News

AHPA  and CRN have issued new policies on caffeine labeling.

AHPA, CRN issue new guidelines on caffeine labeling

Cracker Jack'D strategically rolled out in convenience stores to target adults, not kids, says Frito-Lay

Frito-Lay: Cracker Jack’D caffeinated snacks do not target kids

“The brain of children is extremely plastic…”

Caffeine slows growth of ‘children’s plastic brains’: Rat study

Euromonitor analyst looks at what the future of the energy supplement market looks like beyond caffeine

Beyond caffeine: Alternative energy boosters

"If people underestimate their level of intoxication after consuming AMED [alcohol mixed with energy drink] or alcohol and caffeine compared to alcohol only, they may be more likely to engage in potentially dangerous alcohol-related activities," say researchers.”Photo credit: Stuart Richards.

You’ll regret it in the morning: Review suggests alcohol-caffeine combo does not ‘mask’ intoxication

Caffeine level remains the key concern for consumers - but a 'natural' source claim can take a product to a different positioning, according to Mintel

‘Artificial’ caffeine is becoming a blacklisted ingredient: Mintel

Single doses of caffeine up to 200mg do not raise safety concerns for adults, also when consumed less than two hours before intense exercise, says EFSA

EFSA: 400mg of caffeine a day is safe

Pan-EU max upper limits for caffeine should be set

First things first Europe: Set pan-EU max limit for caffeine

The enzyme NMNAT2 is significantly reduced in Alzheimer’s, Huntington’s and Parkinson’s diseases. ©iStock/XiXinXing

Caffeine may protect brain against dementia, study shows

Study: 12% of adult Europeans consume energy drinks at ‘chronic’ levels

Study: 12% of adult Europeans consume energy drinks at ‘chronic’ levels

EU regulators should define what comprises a 'natural' as opposed to a traditional energy drink, says MyDrink Beverages CEO Adomas Pranevicius

‘Energy drinks’ hit EU hyperspace, but threaten final frontiers

Dan Callahan: 'There is no medical, scientific or factual evidence to support the Maryland Medical Examiner's Report of 'caffeine toxicity' or that Ms. Fournier's consumption of two Monster Energy Drinks 24 hours apart contributed to, let alone was the cause of her untimely death'

Monster attorney: Medical evidence does not support allegation that Maryland teen died from ‘caffeine toxicity’

Caffeine during pregnancy could be linked to a higher risk smaller babies when they are born, warn the researchers.

Caffeine linked to low birth weight babies: Study

Screenshot taken from

'Death by Caffeine': 354 cans of red Coke would kill this journalist

Related Products

See more related products

Comments (3)

yves - 15 Mar 2013 | 09:27

this is another example of alarmist approach

Facts are very soft Banning caffeine because of its purported effect when combined with alcohol is medical "big Brother"ism at its worst J

15-Mar-2013 at 21:27 GMT

Euan Paul M.B.,B.S. - 14 Mar 2013 | 07:32

Caffeine - One sided opinion

I am surprised that you published this alarmist comment from Jack James, a well known anti-caffeine protaganist. This is a personal opinion which is not shared by many peers and puts over an alarmist and skewed viewpoint which may alarm many.

14-Mar-2013 at 19:32 GMT

Submit a comment

Your comment has been saved

Post a comment

Please note that any information that you supply is protected by our Privacy and Cookie Policy. Access to all documents and request for further information are available to all users at no costs, In order to provide you with this free service, William Reed Business Media SAS does share your information with companies that have content on this site. When you access a document or request further information from this site, your information maybe shared with the owners of that document or information.