Open book: The future of probiotic marketing in Europe

EFSA: “The fact we are here is an indication we are willing to commit to dialogue.”

‘Openness’ and ‘better dialogue’ between industry, scientists and regulators were themes of the day as the newly minted European chapter of the International Probiotics Association (IPA-Europe) launched itself with a mini-congress in Brussels yesterday.

And so there was some openness and there was some dialogue, and this is good and progressive, but it is also patently clear that there is a long way to go before probiotic health claims reappear on yoghurt pots and supplement bottles across the EU’s 28 member states. But a united sector helps, and new faces in key EU institutions may prove even more significant.

IPA-Europe – a fusion of the new European branch of the IPA with the now defunct Yoghurt and Live Fermented Milks Association (YLFA) and Global Alliance for Probiotics (GAP) – has made its intentions clear: Win the EU’s first probiotic health claims via dialogue with EU risk assessors and risk managers.

Find a way to convert one of the richest nutrition science archives that exists (10,000+ published pieces of probiotic research) into product messaging that can benefit consumers, public health, innovation, ongoing research and, yes, industry itself.

So the event was a good start, at least symbolically. The European Commission (EC) – the risk manager – was there with its head of nutrition, food composition and information, Alexandra Nikolakopoulou. “We are always open to industry, always open to revisit legislation,” she said encouragingly for the sector before adding: “But the way claims have been assessed so far [since 2008] is perfectly in line with the regulation.”

Risk assessor, the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) was there with its head of nutrition, Valeriu Curtui. “The fact we are here is an indication we are willing to commit to dialogue.”

Vocal critic of the 2006 nutrition and health claims regulation (NHCR), MEP Marion Harkin, was there. She expressed concern about what kind of concrete actions could be taken to end the blockade on claims but said “to hear EFSA say they are open to dialogue is very pleasing – once you have that then you can make progress.”

Academia, as a whole as peeved by the treatment of its probiotic science as industry, was represented too via Dr Lorenzo Morelli, professor and chair of food microbiology and biotechnology at the Instuto Microbiologia at the Universita Cattolica in Piacenza, Italy.

“…an important step forward for probiotics.”

As new IPA-Europe president, and president of Swedish supplier Probi, Peter Nählstedt, told us afterwards, the multi-stakeholder event was an important step forward for probiotics.”

“It does mean a lot to the probiotic industry to have the opportunity to interact with the commission, parliament and EFSA.”

He added: “Having three organisations merge into one I think will strengthen the industry voice on and simplify communications, tonight’s launch event and the newly released document ‘IPA Europe guidelines to qualify a microorganism as probiotic’ are two very tangible examples of that.”

Looking elsewhere…

There were some interesting points raised at the event. About probiotic claim wins in Switzerland from the likes of Yakult, Danone and DuPont-Danisco, where the responsible authority there has apparently followed essentially the same criteria as does EFSA’s NDA health claim panel.

Of Yakult’s recent win, Curtui said, “We haven’t seen that file. We’d like to see it.” See? Open!...

Managing director of Yakult Belgium, Bart Degeest, noted the crucial difference between Switzerland’s Federal Office of Public Health and EFSA was the fact that in non-EU Switzerland an applicant would meet with the regulator to discuss the minutiae of an application before and during the assessment process.

EFSA says it can’t afford such meetings but it has improved communication procedures during ‘stop-the-clock’, the process in place that allows stakeholder interaction when there are queries on submitted health claim dossiers. For many in industry this is too little, too late. And anyway it hasn’t led to a positive probiotic opinion amid 100s of rejections.

What about the claim victories in Canada issued by Health Canada? How open has the dialogue been between regulators on these matters? 

IPA International executive director George Paraskevakos noted the Americas-focused IPA branch had won stakeholder meetings with the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and Brazilian food safety authorities.

In all this it should be remembered the former NDA health claims panel head, Dr Ambroise Martin, predicted in 2011 that the sector would win claims within two years. It didn’t happen as the panel continued rejecting dossiers submitted by heavyweights like Yakult, Chr Hansen, Danone and DuPont-Danisco. 

Perhaps this new era of openness will yield a different result.

Related News

EC launches EU health claims ‘fitness check’; nutrient profiles and botanicals targeted

EC launches EU health claims ‘fitness check’; nutrient profiles and botanicals targeted

IPA chief: "Regulators are starting to turn the corner on probiotics"

IPA chief: "Regulators are starting to turn the corner on probiotics"

Average iron absorption from the probiotic drink was 28.6% compared to 18.5% for the control drink

Probiotics increase iron absorption from fortified drink by 50%: Study

“I think that science needs parts of the process in a closed room and then many steps of the process in an open atmosphere," says EFSA executive director

EFSA’s Bernhard Url: Science should reserve one private room for open debate

Chr Hansen delivers 10% growth as revenues hit €859 million for full year

Chr Hansen delivers 10% growth as revenues hit €859 million for full year

“What we found was that this stabilisation was due to an epigenetic mechanism when human cells were exposed to the heat-treated probiotics."

Working dead? Nestlé scientists find heat-treated ‘zombie’ probiotics can boost immunity beyond the grave

Will you join the likes of Coca-Cola, Danone, General Mills, Pepsi, Seven Seas, Solgar and Nestlé on Tuesday morning?

Invested in prebiotics & probiotics? This is your event

Increasing uptake, not just intake of iron could reduce side effects associated with high iron supplementation, says Probi

Iron absorption probiotic marks ‘new approach’

The Italian advertising standards body called marketing of a cystitis-fighting cranberry product 'highly misleading'. Image © / designer491

Ad body ruling shows Italy’s increasing stray from EU food law

Swiss dairy company Emmi has taken full control of German firm Gläserne Molkerei

Emmi takes over Gläserne Molkerei

Emmi products had mixed results in 2015 globally

Emmi happy despite decline

Probi is looking to take L. Rhamnosus LB21 and Lactococcus lactis L1A into dairy products. © iStock

Swedes form probiotic partnership on 2 (+2) strains

Probi is currently awaiting the verdict on a response to its 13.5 health claim stating: “Lactobacillus plantarum 299v increases non-heme iron absorption.”

Iron absorption probiotic hits Swedish shelves

Chr Hansen's human health and nutrition division performs well - while animal health faces contract challenges. © / horkins

Downturn in yoghurt probiotic use propped up by supplements: Chr Hansen CFO

Probi posted net sales of 87 million Swedish Kroner (€9.49m) in what it called 'a new record quarter' of 26% growth compared to Q1 in 2015. © / shironosov

Probi makes medical moves with its largest distribution deal to date

The International Probiotics Association (IPA) now counts 58 companies as members – up from 42 back in April 2015. © / pvachier

IPA 'rebirth' sees probiotic membership surge

'We need to make sure that we talk to them eye to eye and not come across as the big global player.'

DuPont nutrition & health chief: We want to work with start-ups

'We grew very well with several of our supplement customers but we have also seen a few customers not being successful with supplement launches,' says CFO. © / pvachier

Chr. Hansen posts more ‘modest’ results for EU human health

'Should this conclusion persist – the conclusion would have to be that it can’t be possible to get a health claim for probiotics,' says Probi CEO after claim rejection. ©iStock/benjaminec

310th probiotic claim rejection: EFSA throws out Probi claim for iron absorption

IPA says manufacturing process, not 'contamination,' accounts for traces of gluten researchers found in probiotics

IPA says manufacturing process, not 'contamination,' accounts for traces of gluten researchers found in probiotics

IPA Europe is focused on winning EU probiotic health claims

IPA gathers forces in Brussels; seeks EC ear

Goal for IPA to become more agile, vocal in promoting probiotics, new director says

Goal for IPA to become more agile, vocal in promoting probiotics, new director says

IPA-Europe: “There is a critical situation in the EU so we realised we needed to speak with one voice."

3 into 1: Euro probiotics sector unites as sector sales drop 8%

Carine Lambert: "Coke can have [new variant] ‘Coke Life’, but a probiotic can’t even be called a ‘live culture’.”

Probiotic sector chief: ‘I am ashamed how the EU is dealing with this’

Consultant on the draft consultation: “We do not see any new path to win claims."

EFSA issues immune and gut health claim guidance; 'It will be better for all concerned'

Researchers say strong justification of the use of multiple strain evidence in health claim dossiers is needed to win EFSA over

How can reviews be used to get a probiotic health claim?

Related Products

See more related products

Comments (2)

Gb - 22 Oct 2015 | 08:15

probiotic claims

One need to really understand the science behind probiotics before generalizing and making sweeping comments like probiotic food products are a cocktail...

22-Oct-2015 at 20:15 GMT

yves Delatte - 02 Oct 2015 | 10:52

probiotics "claims"

Ok, some probiotics have a real scientific back-up, but it has to be said that, on the health food shelves, 99% of so-called probiotics are cocktails without any sense. As if no one knows how to make them, nor how does our immune system and digestive system works.

02-Oct-2015 at 10:52 GMT

Submit a comment

Your comment has been saved

Post a comment

Please note that any information that you supply is protected by our Privacy and Cookie Policy. Access to all documents and request for further information are available to all users at no costs, In order to provide you with this free service, William Reed Business Media SAS does share your information with companies that have content on this site. When you access a document or request further information from this site, your information maybe shared with the owners of that document or information.