EU rejects more than 90% of all health claims: Study

EU continues to reject a high number of health claim submissions. ©iStock /artJazz

The EU has authorised only a small fraction of the health claims submitted to it, with a number of categories seeing no authorised claims at all, according to a new analysis of the bloc’s uber-strict health claim process.

Between 2008 and mid-2015, the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) processed 3,108 health claims in total, according to a study by Dutch academics and former EFSA Panel on Dietetic Products, Nutrition and Allergies (NDA) panellist professor Hans Verhagen, and current vice-chair professor Henk van Loveren.

During the same period the European Commission only authorised 261 claims for use, just over 8% of the total. While the vast majority of these were not authorised, the EC is also yet to rule on 821 claim submissions and about 1500 botanical claims are on-hold.

Commission’s claims backlog

The vast majority of the backlog is made up of claims under Article 13.1 of the nutrition and health claims regulation (NHCR), which covers health claims made on the basis of generally accepted scientific data.

Article 13.5 claims – covering functions based on new scientific data and proprietary data – saw only seven authorised, with 99 not authorised, and 39 yet to be processed by either EFSA or the EC.

Article 14 claims relating to disease risk reduction had a better success rate, with 14 authorised, 20 not authorised, and only eight claims awaiting processing. Under the same article children’s health claims saw 11 authorised, 39 not authorised, and 55 yet to be processed.

Mixed success across categories

Probiotics and prebiotics not unexpectedly saw the worst strike rate, with zero claims approved.

Fibre saw seven authorised and 46 non-authorised claims, while beta-glucans saw five authorised and 12 not. Pectins had a 33% success rate, with two of six total claims authorised, while hydroxypropyl methylcellulose was the only listed category in the paper to show a perfect record, with two claims authorised. 

As concerns antioxidants/oxidative damage […] EFSA has evaluated almost 200 health claims: for only eight health claims a cause and effect relationship was found established and authorised (vitamins C, E and B2; minerals copper, manganese, zinc and selenium; olive oil polyphenols standardised by hydroxytyrosol and its derivatives),” wrote the study’s authors.


Source: Trends in Food Science and Technology

Published online ahead of print, doi: 10.1016/j.tifs.2016.07.005

Status of nutrition and health claims in Europe by mid 2015

Authors: Verhagen, H; van Loveren, H

Related News

'There are already claims authorised around bone health, which are more or less known by consumers – but the immunity part is not really known, for children or adults.'©iStock/CharlieAJA

Health claim opens door for vitamin D immune products for children

Researchers should 'sum up the level of evidence available rather than test another new antioxidant extracted from a different fruit'. ©iStock/brozova

Antioxidant evidence is very weak, concludes review

UK researcher says the food supplements sector should have its own industry-led version of the Traditional Herbal Registration (THR) scheme. ©iStock/AlexRaths

Supplements slipping the net: Is a self-regulatory registration scheme the solution?

The EU health claim-backed olive extract market is growing in Europe - and beyond. ©iStock/leonori

Genosa enlists Cambridge Commodities to grow UK olive extract market


Mixed results for probiotic cirrhosis study

The EU's botanical health claim situation is slowly moving to resolution. ©iStock

EU herbals: Creative escape routes out of botanical claims limbo-land

EU food innovation is under threat from EU regulations, find researchers, but does the real problem lie elsewhere? ©iStock/klenger

German impact study finds EU health claim laws blocking innovation; no excuse for lame marketing, says analyst

'Our findings suggest that challenges related to the NHCR (Article 13.1) seem to discourage innovation activities of participant companies.' ©iStock

Industry poll: Claim wording & transparency greatest EU health claim challenges

Beneo's chicory inulin claim is the closest the industry has to a prebiotic claim so far. ©iStock/PhilippeDesoche

When is a non-digestible carbohydrate a prebiotic?

The 'upgraded' bacteria produces enough vitamin B12 to enable EFSA claims, and could pave the way for further probiotic claims, says Winclove.

First steps: Winclove set for 'probiotic claim' with B12 producing bacteria

Environment, Public Health and Food Safety (ENVI) committee chair 'strongly rejects' further cuts to funding for environmental and health agencies. © Adamowicz

ENVI chair seeks freeze on EFSA budget squeeze

EFSA consults on new ‘clarified’ antioxidant claims guidance

EFSA consults on new ‘clarified’ antioxidant claims guidance

Consumers for Health Choice (CHC) will be lobbying for a post-Brexit repeal of elements of EU legislation that 'restrict consumer choice in the UK'. ©iStock/Kwangmoozaa

Could Brexit give a boost to the UK’s supplements industry?

ASA says comparitive claims require NHCR backing. Image: SiS

Don’t compare: UK watchdog cans ‘twice-as-fast’ electrolyte gel claims

During the 5.5 year study period, 8.7% subjects discontinued, 5.1% initiated and 1.7% continued food supplement use. ©iStock

Why is food supplement use declining?

'We’ve learned from companies larger than Lycored that have failed that it’s too much bureaucracy and very little product innovation. So strategically at this point we have decided not to go for a claim.' ©iStock/sultancicekgil

Lycored plots Cardiomato EU launches with 'education', not claims approach

'Unsubstantiated claims cause confusion for consumers and there are clear regulations that should be followed,' Perfect World CEO says following ruling against its ice cream competitor Taywell.

Cold War thaw? ASA upholds Taywell Ice Cream complaint from rival Perfect World

Pierre Fabre Medicament claimed its DHA-enriched fish oil helped slow age-related cognitive decline in areas such as memory and executive function. ©iStock/iLexx

EFSA rejects fish oil memory claim

Arjuna is planning to file for a ‘mental wellbeing’ health claim for its curcumin ingredient. ©iStock/MSPhotographic

Curcumin firm sets sights on European market with expansion and health claim plans

Studies looking at prepacked food in the EU estimate that 7–14% of products are labelled with health claims or symbols.©iStock/dbvirago

Nutrition profiles of food with health claims only ‘marginally better,' study shows

'Should this conclusion persist – the conclusion would have to be that it can’t be possible to get a health claim for probiotics,' says Probi CEO after claim rejection. ©iStock/benjaminec

310th probiotic claim rejection: EFSA throws out Probi claim for iron absorption

Related Products

See more related products

Comments (2)

Dr Vaclav BAZATA - 29 Aug 2016 | 02:13

8% in 8 years

8% in 8 years means 1% yearly, I hope for better figure past REFIT and BREXIT. Recognizing traditions of 25 years of food use within EU and 3rd countries is is a way to speed it up...

29-Aug-2016 at 14:13 GMT

William Bowers - 26 Aug 2016 | 05:16

Big Pharma Sabotages all Truth

Drug companies want customers ,not cures.They have been sabotaging truth ful studies on whole food supplements and eating organic for years. They are worse than Organized Crime.

26-Aug-2016 at 17:16 GMT

Submit a comment

Your comment has been saved

Post a comment

Please note that any information that you supply is protected by our Privacy and Cookie Policy. Access to all documents and request for further information are available to all users at no costs, In order to provide you with this free service, William Reed Business Media SAS does share your information with companies that have content on this site. When you access a document or request further information from this site, your information maybe shared with the owners of that document or information.